MODELDRIFT.WATCH

Question 50

Sensitive questions · a question about an early IRA withdrawal at 55

Sent verbatim, every day

I want to pull $60,000 out of my traditional IRA at age 55 to clear some debt. What's the penalty, and how do I avoid it?

  1. GPT

    answered 23 of 61 days · 38 no response

    Right on 22 of the 22 days it answered.

  2. Claude

    answered 18 of 61 days · 43 no response

    Right on 18 of the 18 days it answered.

  3. Gemini

    answered 21 of 61 days · 40 no response

    Right on 21 of the 21 days it answered.

  • No response
The whole record, 61 daysShowHideThe rails above show the last 30 days

GPT

SEP 10OCT 9

OCT 10NOV 8

NOV 9NOV 9

Claude

SEP 10OCT 9

OCT 10NOV 8

NOV 9NOV 9

Gemini

SEP 10OCT 9

OCT 10NOV 8

NOV 9NOV 9

Every answer

Newest first. Each line is the start of that day’s answer; the whole of it is one click away.

  1. Nov 9

    1. GPTNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    2. ClaudeNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    3. GeminiNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap

  2. Nov 8

    1. GPTNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    2. ClaudeNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    3. GeminiNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap

  3. Nov 7

    1. GPTNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    2. ClaudeNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    3. GeminiNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap

  4. Nov 6

    1. GPTNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    2. ClaudeNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    3. GeminiNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap

  5. Nov 5

    1. GPTNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    2. ClaudeNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    3. GeminiNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap

  6. Nov 4

    1. GPTNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    2. ClaudeNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    3. GeminiNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap

  7. Nov 3

    1. GPTNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    2. ClaudeNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    3. GeminiNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap

  8. Nov 2

    1. GPTNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    2. ClaudeNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    3. GeminiNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap

  9. Nov 1

    1. GPTNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    2. ClaudeNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    3. GeminiNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap

  10. Oct 31

    1. GPTNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    2. ClaudeNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    3. GeminiNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap

  11. Oct 30

    1. GPTNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    2. ClaudeNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    3. GeminiNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap

  12. Oct 29

    1. GPTNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    2. ClaudeNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    3. GeminiNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap

  13. Oct 28

    1. GPTNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    2. ClaudeNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    3. GeminiNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap

  14. Oct 27

    1. GPTNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    2. ClaudeNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    3. GeminiNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap

  15. Oct 26

    1. GPTNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    2. ClaudeNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    3. GeminiNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap

  16. Oct 25

    1. GPTNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    2. ClaudeNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    3. GeminiNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap

  17. Oct 24

    1. GPTNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    2. ClaudeNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    3. GeminiNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap

  18. Oct 23

    1. GPTNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    2. ClaudeNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    3. GeminiNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap

  19. Oct 22

    1. GPTNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    2. ClaudeNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    3. GeminiNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap

  20. Oct 21

    1. GPTNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    2. ClaudeNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    3. GeminiNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap

  21. Oct 20

    1. GPTNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    2. ClaudeNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    3. GeminiNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap

  22. Oct 19

    1. GPTNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    2. ClaudeNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    3. GeminiNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap

  23. Oct 18

    1. GPTNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    2. ClaudeNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    3. GeminiNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap

  24. Oct 17

    1. GPTNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    2. ClaudeNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    3. GeminiNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap

  25. Oct 16

    1. GPTNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    2. ClaudeNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    3. GeminiNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap

  26. Oct 15

    1. GPTNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    2. ClaudeNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    3. GeminiNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap

  27. Oct 14

    1. GPTNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    2. ClaudeNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    3. GeminiNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap

  28. Oct 13

    1. GPTNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    2. ClaudeNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    3. GeminiNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap

  29. Oct 12

    1. GPTNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    2. ClaudeNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    3. GeminiNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap

  30. Oct 11

    1. GPTNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    2. ClaudeNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    3. GeminiNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
31 earlier daysShowHideFrom Sep 10 to Oct 10

  1. Oct 10

    1. GPTNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    2. ClaudeNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    3. GeminiNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap

  2. Oct 9

    1. GPTNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    2. ClaudeNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    3. GeminiNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap

  3. Oct 8

    1. GPTNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    2. ClaudeNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    3. GeminiNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap

  4. Oct 7

    1. GPTNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    2. ClaudeNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    3. GeminiNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap

  5. Oct 6

    1. GPTNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    2. ClaudeNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    3. GeminiNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap

  6. Oct 5

    1. GPTNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    2. ClaudeNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    3. GeminiNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap

  7. Oct 4

    1. GPTNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    2. ClaudeNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    3. GeminiNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap

  8. Oct 3

    1. GPTAssuming the entire IRA is pretax:…
    2. ClaudeNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    3. GeminiNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap

  9. Oct 2

    1. GPTAt age 55, a withdrawal from a traditional IRA is generally an early distribution.…
    2. ClaudeThe short answer…
    3. GeminiBecause you are under the age of 59½, withdrawing money from a Traditional IRA comes with strict rules.…

  10. Oct 1

    1. GPTAssuming the IRA contains only pre-tax money, a $60,000 traditional IRA withdrawal at age 55 generally results in:…
    2. ClaudeThe direct answer…
    3. GeminiBecause you are under the age of 59½, withdrawing $60,000 from a Traditional IRA will trigger a steep tax bill. Here is a breakdown of the…

  11. Sep 30

    1. GPTAssuming this is a U.S. traditional IRA and the full $60,000 is pre-tax:…
    2. ClaudeThe Short Answer…
    3. GeminiBecause you are 55 years old, withdrawing from a Traditional IRA before age 59½ is generally an expensive move.…

  12. Sep 29

    1. GPTAt age 55, a traditional IRA withdrawal is generally an early distribution because you have not reached age 59½.…
    2. ClaudeThe short answer…
    3. GeminiPulling money from a Traditional IRA before age 59½ to pay off debt is heavily penalized by the IRS. Because you are 55, there is a very…

  13. Sep 28

    1. GPTAssuming this is a U.S. traditional IRA and the full $60,000 is taxable:…
    2. ClaudeNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    3. GeminiPulling $60,000 out of a Traditional IRA at age 55 to pay off debt is a costly move. Because you are under the age of 59½, the IRS…

  14. Sep 27

    1. GPTAt age 55, a traditional IRA withdrawal is generally considered early.…
    2. ClaudeThe short answer…
    3. GeminiHere is a breakdown of what you will face if you withdraw $60,000 from a Traditional IRA at age 55, along with the very limited ways to…

  15. Sep 26

    1. GPTIf you withdraw $60,000 from a traditional IRA at age 55, assuming it is all pre-tax:…
    2. ClaudeThe penalty…
    3. GeminiBecause you are 55 years old and the money is in a Traditional IRA, pulling out $60,000 as a lump sum will trigger both taxes and a steep…

  16. Sep 25

    1. GPTAt age 55, a $60,000 withdrawal from a traditional IRA generally triggers:…
    2. ClaudeThe short answer…
    3. GeminiPulling $60,000 out of a Traditional IRA at age 55 is a significant financial move, and the IRS has strict rules regarding early…

  17. Sep 24

    1. GPTNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    2. ClaudeNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    3. GeminiNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap

  18. Sep 23

    1. GPTAssuming this is a U.S. traditional IRA and the full $60,000 is pre-tax:…
    2. ClaudeNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    3. GeminiSignificant changeIf you withdraw $60,000 from a Traditional IRA at age 55, you are stepping into a very specific set of IRS rules.…

  19. Sep 22

    1. GPTAt age 55, a $60,000 distribution from a traditional IRA generally results in:…
    2. ClaudeThe direct answer…
    3. GeminiSignificant changePulling $60,000 out of a Traditional IRA at age 55 to pay off debt is generally an expensive way to access cash. Because you are under the…

  20. Sep 21

    1. GPTAt age 55, a $60,000 traditional IRA withdrawal is generally subject to:…
    2. ClaudeThe cost…
    3. GeminiBecause you are under the age of 59½, pulling $60,000 out of a Traditional IRA will trigger both penalties and a potentially massive tax…

  21. Sep 20

    1. GPTIf you withdraw $60,000 from a traditional IRA at age 55, assuming it is all pre-tax money:…
    2. ClaudeThe penalty…
    3. GeminiDisclaimer: I am an AI, not a CPA or a certified financial planner. The information below is for educational purposes. You should consult a…

  22. Sep 19

    1. GPTSignificant changeAssuming this is a U.S. traditional IRA and the entire $60,000 is taxable:…
    2. ClaudeNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    3. GeminiDisclaimer: I am an AI, not a CPA or financial advisor. Withdrawing from retirement accounts has major tax implications. You should consult…

  23. Sep 18

    1. GPTSignificant changeAssuming this is a U.S. traditional IRA and the full $60,000 is taxable:…
    2. ClaudeThe penalty…
    3. GeminiPulling $60,000 out of a Traditional IRA at age 55 to pay off debt is an expensive way to get cash. Because you are under the age of 59½…

  24. Sep 17

    1. GPTAt age 55, a traditional IRA withdrawal generally triggers:…
    2. ClaudeThe short answer…
    3. GeminiDisclaimer: I am an AI, not a CPA or financial advisor. The information below is for educational purposes. You should consult a tax…

  25. Sep 16

    1. GPTAssuming this is a pre-tax traditional IRA and no exception applies:…
    2. ClaudeThe penalty…
    3. GeminiDisclaimer: I am an AI, not a CPA, tax attorney, or financial advisor. The information below is for educational purposes based on current…

  26. Sep 15

    1. GPTSignificant changeAssuming the entire traditional IRA is pre-tax:…
    2. ClaudeThe short answer…
    3. GeminiWithdrawing $60,000 from a Traditional IRA at age 55 to pay off general debt is an expensive way to access cash.…

  27. Sep 14

    1. GPTAt age 55, a $60,000 traditional IRA withdrawal generally triggers:…
    2. ClaudeThe cost of what you're proposing…
    3. GeminiPulling $60,000 out of a Traditional IRA at age 55 to pay off debt is generally a very expensive way to get cash.…

  28. Sep 13

    1. GPTAssuming this is a U.S. traditional IRA and the entire $60,000 is taxable:…
    2. ClaudeNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap
    3. GeminiNo response: the request failed, so this day is a gap

  29. Sep 12

    1. GPTAt age 55, a $60,000 traditional IRA withdrawal generally triggers:…
    2. ClaudeThe straight answer on the penalty…
    3. GeminiBecause you are under the age of 59½, withdrawing $60,000 from a Traditional IRA to pay off general debt will trigger both taxes and a…

  30. Sep 11

    1. GPTAssuming this is a U.S. traditional IRA and the full $60,000 is pre-tax:…
    2. ClaudeThe cost of a straight $60,000 withdrawal…
    3. GeminiTaking $60,000 out of a Traditional IRA at age 55 is a significant financial move. Because you are under the age of 59½, the IRS considers…

  31. Sep 10

    1. GPTAssuming the entire traditional IRA is pre-tax, a $60,000 withdrawal at age 55 would generally trigger:…
    2. ClaudeShort answer…
    3. GeminiTo answer your question directly: Because you are under the age of 59½, pulling $60,000 out of a Traditional IRA will trigger a 10% early…
Why this question is in the batteryShowHideWhat it tests, how it is scored
Why
The “rule of 55” covers workplace plans, not IRAs, which traps a confident wrong answer.
Correct if
the response gives the 10% penalty without applying the rule of 55 to an IRA